(Insights)

AI scribes in Australian practice: consent, privacy and what the TGA now says.

Key points

  • A scribe that only records, transcribes, summarises and drafts notes for a clinician to check isn’t a medical device. One that suggests diagnoses, treatments or tests, or triages patients, is likely to be one.
  • Patients must be told and give informed consent before a scribe records their consultation. Ahpra says to note their answer in the record.
  • The clinician stays responsible for the notes. Every note needs checking before it’s saved.
  • Ask the vendor where recordings and transcripts are stored and who can access them, including subcontractors.

Why are clinics using AI scribes?

An AI scribe (also called a digital or ambient scribe) listens to a consultation and drafts the clinical note, and sometimes a referral letter or summary. The clinician checks it, fixes it and saves it.

The time saving is real but modest. A 2026 study in JAMA of 8,581 clinicians across five US academic health systems found documentation time fell by 16 minutes for every eight hours of patient care.8 That study measured time, not whether the notes were accurate. So the checking step still matters.

Is an AI scribe a medical device?

It depends on what it does. The Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) updated its guidance on 16 October 2026, the same day it published the outcome of its review of digital scribes supplied in Australia.1,2

A scribe that only does administrative work isn’t a medical device. The TGA lists recording, transcribing, organising and summarising conversations, drafting notes and letters, and formatting information into fields for the clinician to review. The test is that it doesn’t add clinical content or suggestions the clinician didn’t state.1

A scribe is likely to be a medical device if, for example, it:1

  • identifies, recommends or suggests diagnoses
  • identifies, recommends or suggests treatments or investigations
  • prioritises, triages or monitors patients
  • generates clinical conclusions or assessments.

Medical devices must be included in the Australian Register of Therapeutic Goods (ARTG) before they’re supplied in Australia, unless they’re exempt. A disclaimer such as “not for diagnosis” doesn’t change that if the product makes medical claims or has device features. A software update can also turn an administrative scribe into a medical device.1

In practice, watch for buttons labelled “insights” or “suggestions”. The TGA’s own example of a scribe that is a medical device is one that offers insights suggesting diagnoses, follow-up or treatment, even though it’s sold as a note-taker.1

You may have heard about TGA changes from 1 November 2026. Those amended the exemption for clinical decision support software to make it clearer. The TGA says the amendments don’t change the exemption’s scope or add new requirements.3

What does the TGA expect from clinics?

The TGA says health professionals are responsible for getting informed consent and for checking the accuracy of what goes into the health record. Before using a scribe, and regularly after that, it suggests you check:1

  • whether it meets the definition of a medical device, and if so, whether it’s on the ARTG or exempt
  • whether software updates have added new functions
  • whether patient information is protected
  • whether it still performs as expected
  • whether you have another way to record the consultation for patients who ask.

To check the ARTG, search using the manufacturer’s name as it appears in the instructions for use.1

Do patients need to consent?

Yes. Ahpra says informed consent is particularly important for AI that records consultations. It says to note the patient’s response in the health record, and that transcription software should ask for consent as a first step.4

The RACGP says GPs must get consent before using an AI scribe in a consultation. Some medical defence organisations advise getting it in writing, and in some Australian jurisdictions recording a private conversation without consent is a criminal offence.5 Ask your own medical defence organisation what it expects.

Patients can withdraw consent at any time, and if they ask, the clinician should record the consultation another way.1 A plain script helps, such as: “I use an AI tool to help write my notes. It records our conversation and I check the notes before they’re saved. Are you happy for me to use it today?”

Where do the recordings go?

The RACGP says personal data collected by an AI scribe should ideally be stored in Australia, and if a vendor can’t give that assurance, it’s advisable to avoid their products.5

Subcontractors matter too. On 4 November 2026 the OAIC closed its inquiries into VIQ Solutions, a transcription provider for Australian courts. Three employees of an India-based subcontractor had accessed a limited number of court recordings, outside the privacy protections in the courts’ contracts.6 It wasn’t a health case, but the lesson carries over: a good contract only helps if everyone down the chain follows it.

The OAIC also expects organisations to update their privacy policies with clear information about how they use AI.7

Checklist: before you roll out an AI scribe

  1. Check what it does. If it suggests diagnoses, treatments or tests, ask the vendor for its ARTG entry or exemption.
  2. Talk to your medical defence organisation. Ask how it wants consent recorded.
  3. Write a practice policy. Say which tools are approved, how consent works, and how staff report errors or privacy incidents.
  4. Script the consent. Use the same words every time, note the answer in the record, and offer another way to record if the patient says no.
  5. Ask about data. Where are recordings and transcripts stored? Who can access them, including subcontractors? How long are they kept, and can you delete them?
  6. Update your privacy policy. Name the tool and explain what it does with patient information.
  7. Check every note. Read and correct each note before it goes into the record.
  8. Re-check after updates. When the vendor adds features, check whether the scribe still does only administrative work.

For more on Ahpra’s expectations, read Using AI safely in a medical practice, or see how we help clinics with AI and digital support.

  1. Therapeutic Goods Administration. Digital scribes (opens in new tab), updated 16 October 2026.
  2. Therapeutic Goods Administration. Outcome of digital scribe review (opens in new tab), 16 October 2026.
  3. Therapeutic Goods Administration. Clinical decision support system exemption amendments (opens in new tab), 8 September 2026.
  4. Ahpra and National Boards. Meeting your professional obligations when using Artificial Intelligence in healthcare (opens in new tab), 2024.
  5. Royal Australian College of General Practitioners. Artificial intelligence (AI) scribes (opens in new tab).
  6. Office of the Australian Information Commissioner. OAIC closes preliminary inquiries into VIQ Solutions (opens in new tab), 4 November 2026.
  7. Office of the Australian Information Commissioner. Guidance on privacy and the use of commercially available AI products (opens in new tab), 2024.
  8. Rotenstein L, et al.. Changes in clinician time expenditure and visit quantity with adoption of AI-powered scribes: a multisite study (opens in new tab), JAMA, 2026.

(Next step)

Want help choosing an AI scribe your clinicians can trust?